Chauniqua Young is an employment attorney and partner at Outten & Golden LLP in New York City, where she has spent more than a decade representing workers in discrimination, pay equity, and wage-and-hour disputes. After law school, she served as a Bertha Justice Fellow at the Center for Constitutional Rights, litigating civil rights cases before joining Outten & Golden as an associate in 2014 and becoming partner in 2021. She has secured significant results for clients, including a $26 million settlement on behalf of Black, Hispanic, and female employees who were underpaid, and she has litigated cases challenging discriminatory compensation policies under the New York City Human Rights Law. Her honors include recognition among The Best Lawyers in America and the Lawdragon 500 Leading Plaintiff Lawyers in America. That record of advocacy for workplace fairness informs her perspective on how employers must validate physical ability tests as genuinely job-related.
Employers sometimes use physical ability tests to measure whether applicants or employees can perform demanding tasks. These tests can involve running a set distance, completing an obstacle course, or lifting and carrying a specified weight. Physical performance tests differ from medical examinations that measure health information.
The main question is whether the test has a demonstrated connection to the work. Under the federal Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures, validation means showing that a selection procedure is job-related. The framework looks for evidence that the test measures work behaviors, skills, or abilities important to successful performance rather than relying on an employer’s belief.
The Uniform Guidelines describe different validation approaches for evaluating whether a selection procedure is useful and appropriately related to the job. Content validity asks whether the test itself adequately represents important job demands. For this approach, a job analysis identifies important work behaviors and related tasks, including their importance or difficulty, so the test content can be compared with the work it is intended to represent.
Criterion-related validity asks a different question: whether test scores have a demonstrated statistical relationship with a separate measure of actual job performance. The focus is not simply on whether the test resembles the work. Instead, the evidence examines whether people who receive different test scores also show corresponding differences on a job-performance measure.
Construct validity focuses on an underlying characteristic or ability that the test is intended to measure. The evidence must support both that the characteristic is important to successful job performance and that the test actually measures that characteristic. This differs from content validity, which compares test content with job demands, and criterion-related validity, which compares test scores with job-performance results.
How the employer uses a test score also matters. Under the Guidelines, evidence supporting a minimum pass-or-fail standard does not necessarily justify ranking applicants above that minimum. A job analysis might establish that workers must be capable of lifting a required weight without establishing that applicants who can lift progressively heavier amounts will perform the job better.
Job-relatedness becomes especially important when a selection procedure causes a disparate impact on a status protected by Title VII. Title VII includes a disparate-impact framework addressing particular employment practices and whether a challenged practice is job-related for the position and consistent with business necessity.
The Dial Corporation case shows why resemblance to real work is not enough by itself. Applicants took a seven-minute test requiring repeated lifting and carrying of 35-pound weights, and women passed at a much lower rate than men. The Eighth Circuit upheld findings that the test was more demanding than the actual work and that the employer had not shown the test explained the claimed reduction in injuries.
Another question is whether a different selection method could serve the same purpose with less adverse impact. The Uniform Guidelines address substantially equally valid alternatives with less adverse impact in appropriate circumstances. Title VII also addresses alternative employment practices.
Documentation gives the validation process a record that others can examine. Relevant records can include the job analysis, test content, evidence connecting it to job performance, statistical methods, cutoff or ranking methods, and alternatives considered. Preserving that material makes the claimed relationship between the test and the actual job something that can be evaluated rather than asserted.
About Chauniqua Young
Chauniqua Young is an employment attorney and partner at Outten & Golden LLP in New York City, where she represents workers in discrimination, pay equity, and wage-and-hour matters. A graduate of Sarah Lawrence College and Cardozo School of Law, she began her career as a Bertha Justice Fellow at the Center for Constitutional Rights and later clerked in the Southern District of New York. She has been named to The Best Lawyers in America and the Lawdragon 500 Leading Plaintiff Lawyers in America.